Quantcast


© 2015 50plus Senior News, All rights reserved.
The Search for Our Ancestry: A ‘Brick Wall’

Angelo Coniglio | Jul 1, 2011, 3:04 p.m.



A situation in which no amount of research can find a particular ancestor or generation of ancestors is called a “brick wall” by genealogists. An example is presented below. Names are changed for privacy and simplification.

Q: From censuses at my public library and passenger manifests on the free site www.ellisisland.org, I determined the year (1908), country, and town of birth of my grandfather, Joseph Brown. The catalog at the free Mormon site https://www.familysearch.org shows that civil records for his European birthplace exist for the years 1809 through 1910.

The information is on several microfilms that I ordered, including 1893–1910. There I found my grandfather’s birth record, with his father’s name (Henry Brown) and age in 1908, and his mother’s name. I figured my great-grandfather’s birth year as circa 1887.

Going back through the birth records, I found information on other direct ancestors: my second-great-grandfather Michael Brown, born in 1858; his father, Peter Brown, age 27; and his mother, Maria Smith, age 25.

Here is where the problem starts. Their ages in 1858 show that my third-great-grandparents, Peter and Maria, were born in about 1831–1833. However, birth records from 1830 through 1834 are missing. Having gone this far, it’s frustrating to know records before 1830 are available and may contain more information, but I can’t “connect” to those records because intermediate records are missing. What can I do?

A: If you show the same persistence, you may extend the record. Working with the microfilms you’ve mentioned, search the birth records around 1858 to determine if Michael Brown had any siblings. Ages of parents on birth records often were off by one, two, or more years, and their ages on siblings’ records may show that they were born before or after the gap in records. Finding the missing information may be as simple as looking at the 1829 or 1835 records.

Failing that, check film lists at https://www.familysearch.org/ and see whether there are records other than birth records. If so, order them. Records of marriages for the years preceding 1858 may contain the marriage record of Peter Brown and Maria Smith. That may show their parents’ names and if they were living or dead in 1858. Then go to the pre-1830 records to search for their parents’ births, to extend the “tree,” even though you don’t know the exact birthdays of some relatives.

For your ancestral town, check whether there are microfilms available for death records. If so, order them. Search for the death record of Peter Brown. It’s after 1858, when his son was born, so check the death records after that year. It’s tedious, but if found, it may give Peter Brown’s parents’ names and if they were living or dead when he died.

While searching for Peter’s death, look for his wife, Maria Smith’s, death record. That should say whether she was a widow or not, which can help you zero in on Peter’s death year. Her record may give the names of her parents, who, of course, were also your ancestors.

Churches recorded baptisms, marriages, and deaths of parishioners. Baptism records may exist for the period 1830–1834. If https://www.familysearch.org/ shows that church records exist for your case, order them. Baptisms were usually shortly after a child’s birth and often give the birth date as “today” or “yesterday.” Though the exact birth date is not given, a baptism record is certainly proof of a child’s existence, and its parents’ names would be shown.

Baptisms carry a bonus: Often the names of the godparents are given, and they may be relatives in whom you are interested. If church records exist, you can confirm the other information you’ve found on civil records.

After all that, if you still haven’t found your ancestors born from 1830–1834, what to do? The previous steps are free or at nominal cost. To go further, you may have to pay. Before resorting to that, “surf” the free site https://www.familysearch.org/. See whether it has online records for the town of interest for the missing years. Sites are regularly updated. You may find a source or actual images of records that just became available. If you still have no luck, try the same approach on www.ancestry.com, a paid site, but with a free trial period.

If none of that works, remember that many towns made duplicate copies. One was kept at the source, but copies may have been sent to provincial or county seats, where the microfilmed records were made. Records missing from those films may still be in existence at the town itself. You may have to write to the appropriate jurisdiction and pay for the desired information. Unfortunately, many municipalities are slow in responding to such requests.

If you have relatives in your ancestral town, they may be able to check the archives. If not, you may have to make a trip to the “old country” to break down that “brick wall”!

 

  Write to Angelo at genealogytips@aol.com or visit his website, www.bit.ly/AFCGen.
He is the author of the book The Lady of the Wheel (La Ruotaia),
based on his genealogical research of Sicilian foundlings.
For more information, see www.bit.ly/SicilianStory.

Angelo F. Coniglio's 50Plus Author's Page

Editor's Picks