309 Myrtle Avenue

 
 

          For years, I have done genealogy research by searching family members' NAMES.  I recently decided to trace newspaper articles that referred to our ADDRESS.  After living in Robertsdale, Pennsylvania from 1913 until about 1920, they had a short stay at 18 Peacock Street in Buffalo's Canal District until about 1922.  Then the family moved to the East Side of Buffalo. They had an upper flat at 309 Myrtle Avenue, where they abided for over twenty years.  I was the only member of my siblings to be born in a hospital, but I was born while we lived at 309 Myrtle.  My memories of the place are vague, and any family members who remember it have passed, but my newspaper search has brought some 'life' back to our stay there.

           The photo below is the only one I have of 309 Myrtle, looking across Seneca Street to the F. N. Burt cardboard box factory.
 

MarToConAnge.jpg (221311 bytes)

Mary, Tony, Connie & Angelo
 at 309 Myrtle Avenue ~ 1941
F. N. Burt factory in the background

 

The F. N. Burt factory
from the empty lot that was 309 Myrtle Avenue.
~ August 2012 ~

 

 

Buffalo Times, 1 October 1922, p. 81

 

           The first clippings I found  reported a kitchen fire at the home.  These are from the Buffalo Times of 1 October 1922, page 81, and a story in Italian from Il Corriere Italiano of 7 October 1922.  Interesting that both the
English and Italian version gave my father Gaetano's name as Guy.
          This date is curious, because his first daughter, Carmela Mary (Millie), born on 27 May 1923, was baptized at
Our Lady of Mount Carmel church, which was in the Canal District, where the family had lived briefly.  Her 1923 baptism record states that her father Cajetano (quasi-Latin for Gaetano) Coniglio's residence was 18 Peacock Street.  So did he have two addresses? Was Millie born at 18 Peacock, or at 309 Myrtle?
 

 

 

Corriere Italiano, 7 October 1922, p. 4

 

 

 

Buffalo Post, 27 August 1925, p. 3

     The "girl twins" whose birth was reported in the Buffalo Post on 27 August 1925 were Concetta Maria (Connie) and Maria Angela (Mary), born on 24 August.  The photo is the earliest I have of them.  With them is Tony, who was born on 3 June 1927.

Connie, Tony and Mary, about 1929

 
        In June of 1927 eldest son Guy (also Gaetano) received the Buffalo Schools' prestigious Jesse Ketchum Award.  It was reported in the Buffalo Evening News on 23 June, and in the Buffalo Times on 5 August.  The News misspelled Gaetano, and the Times misspelled Coniglio.

Ketchum Medal No. 2518

Buffalo Evening News, 23 June 1927, p.6

 

Buffalo Times, 5 August 1927, p16

 
      In Septmber 1928, Guy Jr. evidently decided to run away, as reported in the Buffalo Evening News on 9 September.  He obviously returned, as the Buffalo Times showed on 30 September that he earned another Jesse Ketchum Award.  The  News misspelled Coniglio, but the Times got it right.
 

Buffalo Evening News, 9 September 1928, p. 9

 

Ketchum Medal No. 2322

Buffalo Times, 30 September 1928, p. 41

 
        I don't understand German, but this article in the  Taglicher Buffalo Volksfreund (Buffalo Daily People's Friend) of 29 October 1931 clearly mentions "Leonard Coniglio" and "309 Myrtle".

Taglicher Buffalo Volksfreund, 29 October 1931, p. 8

 
      Turns out "Verschwunden" means "Vanished"!  On the same date as the German newspaper, the Buffalo Evening News reported Leonard missing.  The very next day, he was found and returned home.

Buffalo Evening News, 29 October 1931, p. 31

 

Buffalo Evening News, 30 October 1931, p. 40

       In this 1924 photo, the earliest I have of them, Guy is on the left, Leonard on the right.
       "Running away" apparently was a 'thing' in the day.  I had not known about Guy's exploit, but I knew Leonard tried and succeeded a couple of times, once to join a circus, and again to join the Civil Conservation Corps.  And in his twenties, he left home and joined the Navy.  His ship had just left Pearl Harbor in 1941, the day before the Japanese attacked.  And he was on a different ship in Tokyo Bay in 1945, when the Japanese surrendered.
 
      Here's why searching by name doesn't always yield results. Newspapers seem to have trouble with the name Coniglio, as in this report in the Buffalo Daily Law Journal of 4 June 1935.
 

Buffalo Daily Law Journal, 4 June 1935, p. 2

Mary and Guy's wedding, 29 June 1935
Fellow runaway Leonard was there, on the right.

 

 
      Our family rented the upper flat at 309 Myrtle.  I was too young when we lived there to have any lasting memories of the "neighbors" downstairs, but newspaper articles over the years mentioned numerous tenants: Anzalone, Neeley, Cole, and so on.  Here are a couple of examples, even one indicating that there was once a "Sam's Hotel" at the address.

Dziennik Dla Wszystkich, 15 June 1926, p. 8
 

Buffalo Evening News, 6 December 1927, p. 3
 

Buffalo Evening News, 31 August 1933, p. 17

Buffalo Evening News, 18 October 1938, p. 7
 

Buffalo Courier Express, 24 May 1943, p. 8

 

 
      On 9 Septmber 1936 the Buffalo Daily Law Journal reported a male birth to 'Mr. and Mrs. Gaetano Coniglio'.  That child was me, Angelo, born on 21 August.  The photo is the earliest I have of myself, taken a couple of years later.
 

Buffalo Daily Law Journal, 9 September 1936, p. 4

Angelo on the 'Travelling Pony', about 1937-1938

 
      On 3 April 1937, the Buffalo Daily Law Journal duly reported that Leonard, at the time 21, had bought an eight-year-old 1929 Chevy for seventy bucks.  It's a stock photo, the family didn't own a camera then.
 

Buffalo Daily Law Journal, 3 April 1937, p.4

1929 Chevrolet Coupe, stock photo.

 
      Some of the clippings are prosaic or mundane, but they still shine a light on day-to-day life at 309 Myrtle.  In the 40's, what repairs did Gaetano make at the flat?  What "household furnishings" from the Larkin Company did 'Rose' (Rosa) spend $37.01 for?

Buffalo Evening News, 25 May 1940, p. 10

Buffalo Daily Law Journal 24 May 1940, p. 6
 

Buffalo Daily Law Journal 15 Aug 1942, p. 3

 
      The Buffalo Courier Express reported the marriage license of Raymond and Marian Cappellano in its issue of 14 January 1942.  They married on Valentine's Day, and Ray was drafted and inducted into the Army in June.  He then served in combat, in Africa, Sicily, and Germany.
 

Buffalo Courier Express, 14 January 1942, p. 19

Marian and Ray's wedding, 14 February1942
Felice was there, on the left.

 
      On 2 March 1943, the Courier Express reported that Felice (Phil) had been inducted into the Navy.  He reported shortly after that, and thankfully spent his tour of duty in the States, at Banana River, Florida.

Buffalo Courier Express, 2 March 1943, p. 11

 
      The last clipping citing 309 Myrtle Avenue was actually published after the family had moved, in June 1944, to 973 West Avenue.   Even as I write this, eighty-two years later, it brings tears to my eyes.  It's the 6 July 1944 Courier Express death notice for my father Gaetano, who was struck and killed by a hit-run driver.  The photo, I believe, was the last ever taken of him.

Buffalo Courier Express, 6 July 1944, p. 15

 

 

The following articles were published after the family had moved to 973 West Avenue.

 

Buffalo Evening News, 5 July 1944, p. 27

Courier Express, 5 July 1944, p. 9

 

Buffalo Evening News, 21 May 1945, p. 6

Guy 1939

Len 1941

Ray 1942

Phil 1943

Tony 1945

Millie

Connie

Mary

     This was not in the papers, but it should have been.  All the sisters worked at the Chevrolet defense plant during the war.

 
      The Buffalo Courier Express reported the marriage license of Carmela (Millie) Coniglio and Al Volo in its issue of 24 April 1946, on the same day that they were married.
 

Buffalo Courier Express, 24 April 1946, p. 35

Millie and Al's wedding, 24 April 1946
Felice and Mary on the left, Connie on the far right

 
     Imagine Rosa's grief and dismay when her son Tony was struck by a car on 9 September 1948 (her birthday, no less), as her husband was, four years earlier.  Fortunately, Tony made a full recovery.

Buffalo Evening News, 9 Septemnber 1948, p. 44

Courier Express, 9 Septemnber 1948, p. 17

 
    In 1949, Donald K. Miller was serving in the U. S. Navy on the Training Vessel PC 1208 in Buffalo.

Buffalo Courier Express, 15 May 1949, pp. 6-8
 
     Maria Angela (Mary) and Fiore Denisco's marriage license was posted in 1949 by the Courier Express on 14 August, and the Buffalo Evening News the next day. Still another day later, the Buffalo Daily Law Journal posted it, with Fiore's name misspelled.  They were married on 24 August 1949, on Mary's 24th birthday.
     Fiore means 'flower' in Italian: his family called him 'Fiudi', we called him 'Frank', but he sadly passed away too young, in 1959, the father of two.  Mary remarried, to Frank Sowa in 1962, and had two more children.

Courier Express, 14 August 1949, p. 19
 

Buffalo Evening News, 15 August 1949, p. 14

Buffalo Daily Law Journal, 16 August 1949, p. 2

 
    On Christmas Eve, 1949, A little over a year after Tony was struck by an auto, both the Buffalo Evening News and the Courier Express published notice of Tony's and Frances Knickerbocker's marriage license.  They were married on the 26th, Phil's 29th birthday.

Buffalo Evening News, 24 December 1949, p. 4

Courier Express, 24 December 1949, p. 4

 
     Connie met Don Miller while he was stationed in Buffalo. The Buffalo News and the Corriere Italiano reported their marriage license on 24 and 27 April 1950, and they married on 29 April.
     Don's
parents Sylvester and Shirley Miller came from Danville, Illinois for the wedding.
     After Don was discharged, the couple settled in Danville.

Buffalo Eve. News, 24 Apr. 1950, p. 16

Corriere Italiano, 27 April 1950, p. 2

 

Generations:

Genesis

1

2 3 4

bunnyanimated.gif (21803 bytes)

CompassRose.jpg (2452 bytes)

Gaetano & Rosina

1
Guy

2
Len

3
Ray

4
Phil

5
Millie

6
Connie

7
Mary

8
Tony

9
Ange

Family
List

SerradifalcoCrestModSmall.jpg (4693 bytes)
Serradifalco:

SerraSmal.jpg (5441 bytes)
The First Visit


The SecondVisit

ChiesaMadreSmall.jpg (3842 bytes)
The Church

SocietaSmall.jpg (5131 bytes)
La Societ
à

TheBook.jpg (7040 bytes)
The Book

La Bedda Sicilia

PITTSTON

Robertsdale

Last revision: 22 October 2026 ~ Angelo F. Coniglio, AFConiglio@aol.com

































Hit Counter